Product evaluated: MCARCAR KIT Carbon Fiber Trunk Spoiler Compatible with 2013-2019 Benz CLA-Class C117 W117 4-Door Sedan Rear Boot Lid Highkick Spoiler Wing Lip
Related Videos For You
Easiest Way to Install a Spoiler | Day 8 E36 Build
Data basis: This report draws on dozens of buyer-written reviews and several video demonstrations collected between 2019 and 2024. Most feedback came from written reviews, supported by videos that show installation and wear over weeks.
| Outcome | MCARCAR Spoiler | Typical Mid-range Spoiler |
|---|---|---|
| Fitment & alignment | Mismatch common—fit issues appear repeatedly during first installation and require trimming or re-positioning. | Usually snug—most mid-range parts need light adjustment only. |
| Finish durability | Finish concerns—shiny coating can look uneven and may show early wear in real-world use. | More consistent—peer products often use tougher finishes or thicker coatings. |
| Installation effort | Extra steps—buyers commonly report needing additional prep, tools, or adhesive for secure mount. | Less prep—mid-range options usually include clearer hardware and fewer hidden steps. |
| Paint & adhesive risk | Higher-than-normal risk—reports of paint lift or stubborn residue after removal are more frequent than category norms. | Lower risk—many competitors use removable adhesives or include hardware to avoid paint contact. |
| Regret trigger | Rework required—buyers often spend time and money fixing fit or paint problems. | Minor tweaks—typical alternatives usually need only minor adjustments, rarely rework. |
Why doesn’t this spoiler sit flush on the trunk?
Installation pain: Many buyers report a visible gap or uneven edge during the first fit attempt. Pattern: This is commonly reported and appears repeatedly across owner feedback.
When it happens: The issue shows up during initial installation and worsens if forced into place or glued without test-fitting. Category contrast: This is worse than most mid-range spoilers that usually need minor alignment only.
Could this damage my paint or leave sticky residue?
- Early sign: Buyers commonly notice adhesive residue after a few weeks of use.
- Frequency tier: This is a primary issue in feedback, not universal but occurs often enough to matter.
- Cause: Reported glue strength and tape quality can bond too tightly to factory paint.
- Impact: Some owners report needing paint-safe solvents or professional detailing to remove residue.
- Attempted fixes: Test-fitting, heat application, and slow removal are commonly recommended by owners.
Why does the finish look uneven or start peeling?
- Visual cue: Several buyers mention an uneven gloss or a plastic-like shine that feels cheap.
- Worse over time: This problem commonly appears after exposure to sun, rain, or car washes.
- Frequency tier: This is a secondary but persistent complaint across reviews.
- Why worse than usual: Typical mid-range spoilers often use tougher clear coats that resist early fading.
- Hidden requirement: Owners often add a protective clear coat to prevent long-term peeling or dulling.
- Fixability: Repainting or recoating is possible but adds time and cost beyond typical buyer expectations.
- Context: Problems are more noticeable on lighter colored cars where mismatch is obvious.
Will I need extra tools, parts, or a pro to finish this properly?
- Hidden step: Multiple buyers report needing extra foam pads, stronger adhesive, or sealant to secure the spoiler.
- Installation time: This often adds extra time beyond the advertised simple DIY install.
- Missing hardware: Complaints about lack of bolts, brackets, or clear instructions appear repeatedly.
- When it matters: The burden shows up for owners who expect plug-and-play installation on the first weekend.
- Cost impact: Buying adhesives or paying a pro can push total cost well above the product price.
- Category contrast: Mid-range competitors usually include full hardware and clearer steps, reducing surprises.
- Attempted fixes: Owners often return to a body shop or buy aftermarket brackets to achieve a solid fit.
Illustrative excerpts
Illustrative: "Gap at the edge after first fit, needed trimming and extra adhesive." — Primary pattern.
Illustrative: "Sticky residue left when I removed the tape, cleaners helped but left marks." — Secondary pattern.
Illustrative: "Finish dulled after months of sun; had to spray clear coat." — Secondary pattern.
Who should avoid this
- Owners who value perfect fit: If you expect plug-and-play alignment, this product exceeds normal fitting risk.
- Paint-first buyers: If you cannot tolerate any adhesive contact or paint work, avoid this spoiler.
- Low-effort DIYers: If you don’t want to buy extra tools or hire a pro, this will likely cause regret.
Who this is actually good for
- Experienced DIYers: If you can handle trimming and extra prep, you can get a decent look with time.
- Budget-conscious modifiers: If you accept potential rework and want the carbon look for less money, this is usable.
- Owners near a shop: If you plan a low-cost shop install, you avoid paint risk and alignment headaches.
Expectation vs reality
Expectation (reasonable): Many buyers expect a ready-to-stick spoiler that fits with minimal work, which is standard for mid-range parts.
Reality: This product often requires extra prep, extra adhesive, or trimming, creating more work than typical alternatives.
Expectation: A durable finish that survives weather is reasonable for this category.
Reality: Several owners report early dulling or uneven gloss, meaning you may need to recoat to preserve appearance.
Safer alternatives
- Choose bolted options: Prefer spoilers that include bolts and brackets to avoid adhesive paint contact.
- Look for fuller kits: Pick sellers who include hardware, instructions, and trim templates to reduce hidden steps.
- Pick reinforced finishes: Prioritize parts advertised with heavy-duty clear coats or UV resistance to avoid recoating.
- Budget for prep: If buying this piece, plan for extra tape, cleaner, and possibly a pro to prevent paint issues.
The bottom line
Main regret trigger: The combination of fit problems and higher-than-normal paint/adhesive risk causes most buyer regret.
Why it matters: These issues add time, cost, and possible paint work beyond what buyers expect for a mid-range spoiler.
Verdict: Avoid this product if you want a low-risk, plug-and-play upgrade; consider it only if you accept extra prep and possible rework.
This review is an independent editorial analysis based on reported user experiences and product specifications. NegReview.com does not sell products.