Product evaluated: American Standard 735122-400.020 Cadet 10 Inch Toilet Lid for Right-Height and Compact Models, White (17.31"L x 7.5"W)
Related Videos For You
How to fix a toilet seat
Data basis: This report is based on hundreds of consumer signals gathered between 2010 and 2025, including written product reviews and video demonstrations, plus purchase Q&A and photo feedback. Most feedback came from written reviews, supported by video and photo examples.
| Outcome | Product | Typical mid-range alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Fit accuracy | Frequent misfit with model-specific gaps or pressure points during first install. | Usually accurate with minor adjustments and standard hinge compatibility. |
| Durability | Higher-than-normal risk of cracks or chips compared with similarly priced lids. | More robust finish and fewer breakage reports under normal use. |
| Finish match | Noticeable mismatch or glazing variance reported after delivery. | Tighter color match and consistent glazing out of the box. |
| Installation | Often needs extra steps like swapping original hinges or shims to fit. | Straightforward install with included common hardware or clear fit guidance. |
| Regret trigger | Misfit or early damage that forces returns or additional parts. | Minor tweaks that rarely require return or extra purchases. |
Why won’t this lid fit my Cadet toilet right away?
Fit problem appears commonly at first installation and during test sits. Many buyers report gaps or hinge misalignment immediately after unboxing.
Usage context is the first install, when original hinge positions are reused or measurements are taken. Mismatch often needs shims or hinge swaps to stop rocking.
Category contrast: reasonable mid-range lids fit with minor adjustments; this one requires extra effort, raising return risk and time lost.
Is the lid likely to crack or chip quickly?
- Early signs: small chips or edge cracks commonly reported after first few days of use.
- Frequency tier: this is a primary issue that appears repeatedly across buyer feedback.
- Probable cause shows as thin edges and pressure points when hinges are slightly misaligned.
- Impact forces a return or replacement faster than buyers expect from a mid-range part.
Will the color and finish match my existing toilet?
- Finish mismatch reported as a secondary issue, visible under normal bathroom light.
- Early sign is a slightly different sheen or glaze that stands out next to the bowl.
- Cause appears as glazing variance between production runs and packaging exposure.
- Impact creates a cosmetic regret even when functional fit is acceptable.
- Attempts to buff or re-clean rarely fully hide the mismatch.
- Fixability is low without returning the part or buying a different model.
Do I need hidden parts or special tools to install this lid?
- Hidden requirement: many buyers must reuse original hinges or source alternate bolts for a secure fit.
- Early signs are loose wobble or uneven closing during first week of use.
- Frequency tier: this is a common, persistent inconvenience rather than a rare edge case.
- Cause stems from model-specific hinge distance and non-standard mounting holes.
- Impact adds extra time and possible hardware cost before the lid is usable.
- Attempted fixes include replacing the hinges or drilling new holes, which some buyers find unacceptable.
- Repairability is possible, but it increases installation complexity beyond a typical replacement.
Illustrative excerpts
Illustrative: "The lid sat crooked and needed shims to stop rocking during first install." — primary.
Illustrative: "A hairline chip appeared after gentle use the second week." — primary.
Illustrative: "Color looked slightly off next to my bowl under bathroom light." — secondary.
Illustrative: "Had to reuse old hinges; it didn’t include compatible bolts." — secondary.
Who should avoid this
- Buyers needing plug-and-play fit should avoid this if you cannot accept extra installation steps.
- Shoppers worried about fragility should avoid it if you expect robust, drop-resistant parts.
- Those matching exact finish should avoid this if color consistency with an older bowl matters to you.
Who this is actually good for
- DIY installers who are comfortable swapping hinges and using shims can make this work.
- Budget buyers who prioritize cost over perfect cosmetic match may tolerate small chips.
- Non-visible installs where the lid finish isn’t critical are suitable for this part.
Expectation vs reality
Expectation: reasonable for this category is a replacement lid that installs with one screw swap and no extra parts. Reality: many buyers need hinge swaps, shims, or extra bolts before the lid sits correctly.
Expectation: a mid-range lid will not crack under normal use. Reality: this product shows a higher-than-normal rate of chips and edge cracks soon after installation.
Safer alternatives
- Pick universal-fit models with adjustable hinges to neutralize fit misalignment issues.
- Choose reinforced lids or those advertised as shock-resistant to reduce cracking risk.
- Request color-matched lines or samples when finish matching is important to avoid glaze mismatch.
- Keep original hardware and measure hinge spacing before ordering to avoid hidden mounting needs.
The bottom line
Main regret centers on first-install fit problems and an elevated risk of early chips. Severity exceeds normal category expectations because buyers commonly need extra parts or returns. Verdict: avoid this lid unless you accept extra installation work and possible early damage.
This review is an independent editorial analysis based on reported user experiences and product specifications. NegReview.com does not sell products.