Product evaluated: Magnesium 5000 (10lb) Calming/Metabolism/Muscle Function Support for Horses.
Related Videos For You
How to Mix Powder Supplements with Horse Feed
The 7 Golden Rules Of Feeding Horses
Data basis: I analyzed dozens of user reviews and seller Q&A entries, plus several photo reports collected Jan 2021 through Dec 2025, with most feedback coming from written reviews supported by photos and Q&A notes.
| Outcome | Magnesium 5000 | Typical mid-range alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Palatability | Often refused — commonly reported feeding refusal or picky acceptance. | Usually accepted — most mid-range pellets acceptably eaten by horses. |
| Storage stability | Moisture clumps — appears repeatedly as a spoilage risk in transit or humid storage. | More stable — alternatives show less clumping under similar conditions. |
| Dosage clarity | Unclear guidance — buyers often report needing extra instructions for safe use. | Clear labeling — typical options include clearer feeding charts and serving tools. |
| Visible results | Inconsistent effects — benefits are less consistent than expected for supplements. | Predictable response — mid-range products usually show steadier outcomes for most horses. |
| Regret trigger | High risk — feeding refusal and spoilage lead to wasted product more than normal for category. | Lower risk — fewer wasted servings when horses accept the feed. |
Why does my horse refuse these pellets?
Regret moment: Many buyers report the horse refusing the pellets at the feed pan during initial introduction.
Severity: This is a primary complaint and appears repeatedly across written feedback.
Trade-off: Unlike most mid-range supplements, this product is more likely to cause feeding refusal, leading to wasted material and feeding disruption.
Are moisture and clumps going to ruin the bag?
- Early sign: Small clumps in bag appear after delivery or short humid storage.
- Frequency tier: This is a secondary issue that appears repeatedly but not universal.
- Cause: Buyers report moisture exposure during transit or poor storage causing pellet agglomeration.
- Impact: Clumped product is hard to scoop and may be rejected by horses.
- Fixability: Some buyers recommend drying and sieving but note this adds time and effort.
Will I know how much to give and when it helps?
- Dosage confusion: Many buyers find the feeding guidance insufficient for mixed rations.
- Pattern: This is a persistent complaint across written reviews and questions.
- When it shows: Confusion appears during first-week use when owners adjust daily rations.
- Why worse: Compared with category norms, this product is less clear and requires extra calculation.
- Impact on care: Mis-dosing risks ineffective results or unnecessary waste.
- Attempted fixes: Owners often use external charts or consult a vet, adding time and expense.
- Hidden need: There is a hidden requirement for measuring tools or vet dosing in multi-horse settings.
Is the packaging and cost worth the effort?
- Packaging feel: Some buyers report thin bags that dent or tear more easily than expected.
- Value signal: This is a secondary-to-edge issue when buyers compare price-per-serving to alternatives.
- When noticed: Packaging problems show up during unboxing or storage turnover.
- Why worse: Compared to mid-range options, the packaging leads to higher waste if bag is punctured.
- Impact: Damaged bags accelerate moisture exposure and clumping.
- Attempts: Buyers sometimes re-bag into sealed containers, which is extra work.
- Fixability: Re-bagging works but adds cost and handling time.
- Edge-case: Single-horse owners report this is less disruptive than multi-horse barns.
Illustrative excerpts (not real quotes)
Excerpt: "My mare sniffed and walked away at first feed, wasted half a cup." — primary pattern
Excerpt: "Bag arrived with moist spots and several pellets fused together." — secondary pattern
Excerpt: "Label lacked clear daily grams for mixed rations, had to call my vet." — primary pattern
Excerpt: "Thin plastic bag tore on the barn floor during handling." — edge-case pattern
Who should avoid this
- Picky eaters: Avoid if your horse rejects new feeds easily because refusal is a top complaint.
- Humid climates: Avoid if you store feed in high humidity areas due to moisture clumping risk.
- Multi-horse barns: Avoid if you need consistent dosing across horses because dosage guidance is unclear.
Who this is actually good for
- Single-horse owners: Good if you can re-bag and monitor intake, accepting the extra handling.
- Owners with tolerant horses: Good if your horse accepts new pellets readily and shows no refusal.
- Those on a budget: Good if you prioritize price and can manage storage and dosing manually.
Expectation vs reality
Expectation: It is reasonable for this category to expect easy acceptance by most horses.
Reality: In practice, buyers report more refusals than typical supplements, causing wasted servings.
Expectation: Reasonable packaging baseline is durable bags that protect pellets.
Reality: The product often arrives with moisture or thin packaging, increasing spoilage risk.
Safer alternatives
- Choose sealed packaging: Look for supplements with vacuum-sealed bags to prevent clumping and spoilage.
- Pick palatable formulas: Prefer products specifically labeled for taste-tested acceptance by horses.
- Ask for feeding charts: Buy options with clear dosing guides to avoid vet consults and mis-dosing.
- Store in buckets: Re-bag into airtight buckets to neutralize the moisture risk if you keep this product.
The bottom line
Main regret: The primary trigger is frequent feeding refusal and added waste from clumping.
Risk exceed: These problems exceed normal category risk because they lead to usable product loss and extra handling.
Verdict: Avoid this product if you cannot manage extra storage, re-bagging, or vet-guided dosing.
This review is an independent editorial analysis based on reported user experiences and product specifications. NegReview.com does not sell products.